Skip to main content

Stay in Long Island's best hotels!

Filter by:


Star Rating

5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star

Review Score

Wonderful: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Harbor Breeze Villas

Clarence Town

Facing the beachfront, Harbor Breeze Villas offers 5-star accommodations in Clarence Town and features a garden, private beach area and BBQ area. Favorite place to stay on the island! Repeat customer and will definitely stay there again. Clean, comfortable, perfect location for Dean's.

Show more Show less
9.5
Exceptional
11 reviews
Price from
$178.25
per night

Stella Maris Resort Club

Stella Maris

This Stella Maris resort is situated on a hilltop overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. It features 3 outdoor pools, a full-service marina and a restaurant. Guest rooms are tropically decorated. Location and Jill and the team. Amazing

Show more Show less
9.2
Wonderful
24 reviews
Price from
$175
per night

Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort & Villas

Seymourʼs

Situated on a 4-mile talcum powder sand beach, this Galliot Cay resort offers a 5 hour tour of Long Island. The beach was fantastic, sort white sand and clear turquoise water. There were kayaks and paddle boards and the water was calm. one day I saw two dolphins from the beach. We paddled around into the lagoon area north of the resort and saw starfish, stingrays and small sharks. The food at the restaurant was delicious and the staff we helpful. There are bikes available which we used to bike to the Columbus monument (11km return). We also rented a car to see some of the other sights of the island. One highlight was seeing the sharks feeding at Flying Fish marina in Clarence Town when the fishing boats clean their fish and throw the scraps in the water.

Show more Show less
8.8
Excellent
93 reviews
Price from
$295
per night

Serenity - Away From The Things Of Man... Lat23N.c

McKanns

This beachfront property offers access to free Wifi and free private parking. The vacation home consists of 1 bedroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and 1 bathroom.

Show more Show less
Price from
$261
per night

Tropical View Villas

Hartswell (Near Long Island)

Tropical View Villas is located in Williams Town, just a 2-minute walk from Tropic of Cancer Beach. It offers fully equipped houses with gardens and BBQ facilities. Free Wi-Fi is also available. Very comfortable and clean and a short walk to beach!

Show more Show less
9.4
Wonderful
26 reviews
Price from
$275
per night

Sunset Cove

Forbes Hill (Near Long Island)

Sunset Cove offers accommodations in Forbes Hill, a 18-minute walk from Cut Beach. This beachfront property offers access to a balcony and free private parking. Guests can use a garden.

Show more Show less

Rae of Sunshine Villas

Hartswell (Near Long Island)

Both Wifi and private parking are accessible at Rae of Sunshine Villas free of charge.

Show more Show less
Price from
$148.50
per night

FAQs about hotels in Long Island

  • On average, 3-star hotels in Long Island cost $141 per night, and 4-star hotels in Long Island are $266 per night. If you're looking for something really special, 5-star hotels in Long Island cost around $188 per night (based on Booking.com prices).

  • There are 13 hotels in Long Island you can book on Booking.com.

  • Clarence Town, Lower Deadmanʼs Cay, and Buckleys are popular with other travelers visiting Long Island.